Class Research Resources and Assignments

Week 12
View Video of Lecture for Week 12


Social Impact of Climate Change:

Lessons of the Past --
Historical Instances of Climate Reversal

     Dr. Harvey Weiss
          Yale University, Professor of Anthropology & Archaeology and Director, Tell Leilan Project

 

 
 

     "The relatively recent droughts described above persisted from a few years to a few decades. Complex societies can, and do, adapt readily to interannual-to-decadal fluctuations in water availability, but more persistent droughts present a different set of challenges and coping strategies. Multidecadal-to multicentury-scale droughts are now known to have punctuated the warm climate of the Holocene epoch [the past 11,700 calendar years before the present (calendar yr B.P.)]. Furthermore, transitions into and out of these climate shifts can be very abrupt, occurring in less than a decade. The Holocene was once thought to have been climatically stable, but detailed and well-dated paleoclimate records now show that Holocene climate was punctuated by several widespread cooling events....

     How did past cultures respond to the longer, multicentury-scale climate changes that punctuated late Holocene climate?"

Peter B. deMenocal
"Cultural responses to climate change during the late Holocene"


Readings:

Elizaberth Kolbert
2005
"Q&A: A Planetary Problem," The New Yorker, 25 April 2005, pp. 64-73.
Elizaberth Kolbert
2005
"Annals of Science: The Climate of Man-II: The Curse of Akkad," The New Yorker, 2 May 2005, pp. 64-73. [See also Part I of 3 part series]
Harvey Weiss and Raymond S. Bradley
2001
"What drives societal collapse?" Science, 291:609-610.
Peter B. deMenocal
2001
"Cultural responses to climate change during the late Holocene," Science, 292: 667-673.
Harvey Weiss
2000
"Beyond the younger Dryas: Collapse as adaptation to abrupt climate change in ancient West Asia and the Eastern Mediterranean. In Environmental disaster and the archaeology of human response," Environmental Disaster and the Archaeology of Human Response, Edited by Garth Bawden and Richard Martin Reycraft. Maxwell Museum of Anthropology, Anthropological Papers, No. 7: 75-95.
Harvey Weiss and Ginger Booth
2004
ArchaeoSim v2.0, Java-based simulation program for exploring social and natural dynamics of Third Millennium BC Subir (northern Mesopotamia).
20th Century Fox
2004
The Day After Tomorrow: Where Will You Be- [Official website of the forthcoming movie. 28 May 2004] Trailers - Small or Medium or Large streaming capacity
Harvey Weiss and Ginger Booth
2001
Simulations - ArchaeoSim v1.0, Java-based simulation program for exploring social and natural dynamics of Third Millennium BC Subir (northern Mesopotamia).

Supplementary Material

 

Abrupt Shifts in Climate Regimes:

      We are accustomed to thinking of climate change as a gradual, millenia-long process of slow shifts in temperature and rainfall. Nevertheless, abrupt climate change has been a fact of history. Individual countries or entire regions have experienced rapid climate changes that have perturbed agricultural production, disrupted the continuity of fresh water supplies, and forced large populations to migrate. While it is rarely a sole cause of political collapse the wide-scale dislocations that climate changes can engender have often destabilized political regimes in the course of human history.

      In American history, the conditions of the "dust bowl" appear now to have been engendered by a climate anomaly that NASA scientists are beginning to identify as a pattern related to changes in tropical sea surface temperatures. Local farming practices -- including the overplowing of land, the destruction of wind-breaking tree cover and the overtapping of groundwater -- may well have contributed to the severity of the dust bowl conditions, but the driving force behind this abrupt shift in weather may have been a climate phenomena whose origins were thousands of miles away.

      In the 1930s the drought and dust bowl conditions contributed to the mass migration of American farmers to California, and the impact of the dust bowl was considerable in both economic and political terms in American history. Since the 1930s many more people in the world have come to depend upon the seemingly stable and continuous flow of grain surpluses generated in the American mid west. If prolongued drought were to return to this mid-continental region -- for whatever reason -- the social impact would be enormous in scope, contributing to major strains to an international food and grain distribution system upon which China and many other countries in the Third World have come to depend.

 


Further readings:

Spencer Weart
2003
The Discovery of Global Warming (Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 2003) [look particularly at: - "Rapid Climate Change".]
Spencer Weart
2003
"The Discovery of Rapid Climate Change," Physics Today, Vo. 56, 8, (2003),p. 30 ff.
Only within the past decade have researchers warmed to the possibility of abrupt shifts in Earth's climate. Sometimes, it takes a while to see what one is not prepared to look for.
Ocean Studies Board (OSB), Polar Research Board (PRB), Board on Atmospheric Sciences and Climate (BASC)
2002
Abrupt Climate Change: Inevitable Surprises (Washington, D. C., National Academy of Sciences, 2002).
Hodell, David A., et al.
2001
"Solar Forcing of Drought Frequency in the Maya Lowlands," Science, 292 (5520), (18 May 2001) 1367-1370.
Haug, Gerald H., et al.
2003
"Climate and the Collapse of Maya Civilization," Science, 299 (5613), (14 March 2003) 1731-1735.
Alley, R. B., et al.
2003
"Abrupt Climate Change," Science, 299 (5615), (28 March 2003) 2005-2010.
NASA - Goddard Space Flight Center
2004
"NASA Explains "Dust Bowl" Drought," NASA - Goddard Space Flight Center, (18 March 2004).
Kerr, Richard A.
2004
"GLOBAL CHANGE: A Slowing Cog in the North Atlantic Ocean's Climate Machine," Science, 304 (5669), (16 April 2004) 371a-372.


Possible Changes in The "Mediterranean Weather Delivery System"

 

Remember the space image of the weather delivery system that Professor Weiss presented in his lecture? Think about the abrupt climate shift events that he emphasized in the Holocene at the 8.2 kyrbp, the 5.2kyrbp and the 4.2kyrbp and then consider the following:

Consider the NASA picture and when you have the dynamic of this west-to-east moving system clearly in mind click on the following two simulations again and follow through the logic of what might "flip" in the Atlantic thermohaline system if certain thresholds (as yet not fully understood) might be exceeded. This raises the question: What relevance does holocene climate history have to our contemporary circumstance?

Animation: A simplified model of global ocean circulation] Abrupt Climate Change from: Abrupt Climate Change: Should We Be Worried? - Prepared for a panel on abrupt climate change at the World Economic Forum Davos, Switzerland, January 27, 2003," Ocean and Climate Change Institution - Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, (27 January 2003).
    and
Animation: "If too much fresh water enters the North Atlantic..." Abrupt Climate Change: Should We Be Worried? - Prepared for a panel on abrupt climate change at the World Economic Forum Davos, Switzerland, January 27, 2003," Ocean and Climate Change Institution - Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution., (27 January 2003).


* Return to Syllabus *