Class Research Resources and Assignments

Week 16

Review Session

Concluding Lecture - Week 16

Please complete a course evaluation. (Thanks...)
and remember The Party!
HUCE
24 Oxford Street
Friday, 23 May 2008 - 6:00-10:00pm

Summation: Where can we go from here?

 


Taking the longer view... (click the blue marble ...the blue marvel)

 
Stephen H. Schneider (Editor), John O. Niles (Editor), Armin Rosencranz (Editor)
2002
Climate Change Policy: A Survey (Washington, D. C., Island Press, 2002), Chapters 1 and 2, pp. 3-87.
Elizabeth Kolbert
 
2006 
Field Notes from a Catastrophe (New York, Bloomsbury USA, 2006), please read entire book.
Derrick Jensen
 
2006 

"Beyond Hope: Losing hope may kill part of you, but that's actually a good thing," Orion Magazine, (May-June, 2006).

    "THE MOST COMMON WORDS I hear spoken by any environmentalists anywhere are, We're fucked....
    But no matter what environmentalists do, our best efforts are insufficient. We're losing badly, on every front. Those in power are hell-bent on destroying the planet, and most people don't care.
    Frankly, I don't have much hope. But I think that's a good thing. Hope is what keeps us chained to the system, the conglomerate of people and ideas and ideals that is causing the destruction of the Earth...."

Timothy C. Weiskel
 
2000 

"Denying the Evidence: Science and the Human Prospect," in Earth at Risk: An Environmental Dialogue between Religion and Science, Donald B. Conroy and Rodney L. Petersen, (eds.), (Amherst, New York, Humanity Books, 2000), pp. 107-130.

David Roberts
 
2006 

"Peak oil will not help us in the climate change fight," Grist Magazine - Gristmill, (29 May 2006).

Jonathan Shaw
 
2006 

"Fueling Our Future," Harvard Magazine, (May-June 2006).

Jonathan Shaw
 
2006 

"Fueling our Future," Harvard Magazine, (May-June 2006), p. 40.

To help you with Betsy Kolbert's book...some lectures and a live appearance!

Elizabeth Kolbert
 April 6  2006

Elizabeth Kolbert
 May 8, 2006 Lecture to the Commonwealth Club of San Francisco (Commonwealth Club, San Francisco, California, 8 May 2006). Audio Broadcast KQED May 12 2006

and Elizabeth Kolbert - LIVE talk
 May 21, 2006 Lecture to Lexington, Massachusetts (Sponsored by the Lexington Global Warming Coalition and Sustainable Belmont). http://www.lexgwac.org/

and

Stephen H. Schneider
2003
Climate Change - Climate Policy, [ Web version, November 2003]
Stephen H. Schneider
2003
Climate Change - Implications of Uncertainty on Integrated Assessments and Cost-Benefit Analysis of Climate Change [ Web version, November 2003]
BBC - Analysis
2005
"Has the World's Oil 'Peaked'?" BBC - Analysis, (Monday, 16 May 2005).
PBS - Global Warming Special
2005
"Global Warming: The Signs and the Science" PBS, (2 November 2005).

Supplementary Material

Wallace S Broecker
1997
"Thermohaline Circulation, the Achilles Heel of Our Climate System: Will Man-Made CO2 Upset the Current Balance?" Science, 278 (5343), (28 November 1997) 1582-1588.
BBC News - Rubert Wingfield-Hayes - Peking
2005
"Bird Flu in Migrating Geese," BBC News Online, (Sunday, 22 May 2005).
Leonardo DiCaprio
  "Global Warming [Picture This...]" - Video produced by Leonardo CiCaprio in coordination with Greencross International and Global Green. Available through Leonardo DiCaprio's "eco-site" web page.

How is the American media reporting and the public understanding the complexity and subtlety of the issues?
How much is "noise" and how much is "signal?"
Is it any wonder the public is confused? How much of the bewilderment is manufactured confusion?

Media Matters
 2006
"Falwell dismissed scientific evidence on global warming, evangelical efforts to address issue," Media Matters, ( Tuesday, March 14, 2006 12:38PM )
Media Matters
 2006
"In new global warming special, Fox News interviews scientists with industry ties, records of misinformation," Media Matters, (19 May 2006).
Media Matters
 2006
"In special that "gets to the bottom" of global warming debate, Fox featured only skeptics, a small minority among scientists" Media Matters, (22 May 2006).
Limbaugh on Al Gore
 2006
"Du Pont, Limbaugh distorted scientific research to downplay global warming," Media Matters", (23 May 2006).

How do you assess Andrew Revkin's recent respresentation of the "The Global Warming Debate" in the larger context of these "culture wars" in America?

Andrew Revkin
 2006
"Meltdown: Yelling 'Fire' on a Hot Planet," The New York Times - Week in Review, (23 April 2006).

How do you assess Al Gore's appearence on Saturday Night Live in the larger context of these "culture wars" in America? In your estimation, has Al Gore advanced the public understanding of global climate change in this kind of gesture or has he weakened it?

Al Gore
 2006
"SNL: If Al Gore were President," Saturday Night Live, (13 May 2006).
Darren Waters
 2006
"Politician Gore appears at Cannes," BBC News Online, (Saturday, 20 May 2006, 17:43 GMT 18:43 UK Saturday, 20 May 2006, 17:43 GMT 18:43 UK).

 

 In any case, from now on in you will need to tay alert to examples of forthcoming media representations and distortions.... and learn to spot them on your own.
Consider, for example, the problem of "fake news"....

What do you think will be the American response to the new ad campaign by the fossil fuel lobby and its sympathizers at the Competitive Enterprise Institute?

Competitive Enterprise Institute
 2006
"We Call it Life-1" Competitive Enterpris Institute, Ad campaign targeting media in 14 American cities, May 2006.
 2006
"We Call it Life-2" Competitive Enterpris Institute, Ad campaign targeting media in 14 American cities, May 2006.
Myron Ebell
2004
Interview with Myron Ebell - excerpted from "Climate Wars," BBC (20 January 2004)..

Are the "climate wars" really just economic wars in environmental disguise? Can we set aside these political squabbles and look soberly at what is happening in the natural world?

Do we "remember" what can (and already has) happened in nature?
What is our collective memory of what happened in 1938 in New England?

U.S. Work Projects Administration
 1938
Shock Troops of Disaster: The Story of the New England Hurricane (1938)

Can we remember what the world leadership on has been saying ever since the first world wide meeting of environmental ministers in Stockholm, Sweden and the creation of the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) in 1972?

Maurice Strong
 1972 +
The Ethical Challenge of Maurice Strong

What are the prospects for changing the perspective of political leadership or changing the leadership altogether through the electoral process? Consider the assessment of the national correspondant for the Washington Post.

Juliet Eilperin
2005
"'Fight Club Politics'," NPR - Fresh Air, (23 May 2006).

What are the prospects for a global economy predicated upon perpetual growth in light of expected climate change -- induced, in part, -- by increased carbon emissions? Is Jeffrey Sachs being naive? overly optimistic? downright foolish? or is he simply sadly misinformed about industrial culture's capacity for social and political self-transformation?

Jeffrey Sachs
2007
BBC 2007 Reith Lectures

Meanwhile, European scientists, reporters and policy writers continue to urge those of us in the United States both to take the latest science more seriously and to recognize the moral obligations we have on a global scale to act soon and decisively to reverse our carbon usage.

Fred Pearce
2007
Fred Pearce - Science Writer and Author of "With Speed and Violence," Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2 May 2007.
George Manbiot
 2007
"If We Don’t Deal with Climate Change We Condemn Hundreds of Millions of People to Death," Democracy Now, (18 May 2007).

In the final analysis we face an open question:

Do we have the cultural capacity in industrial civilization
(which now must include India and China) to undertake
the changes required for our collective survival
in the time that is alotted to us?



Return to Syllabus